In the planner, delete joinaliasvars lists after we're done with them.
Although joinaliasvars lists coming out of the parser are quite simple, those lists can contain arbitrarily complex expressions after subquery pullup. We do not perform expression preprocessing on them, meaning that expressions in those lists will not meet the expectations of later phases of the planner (for example, that they do not contain SubLinks). This had been thought pretty harmless, since we don't intentionally touch those lists in later phases --- but Andreas Seltenreich found a case in which adjust_appendrel_attrs() could recurse into a joinaliasvars list and then die on its assertion that it never sees a SubLink. We considered a couple of localized fixes to prevent that specific case from looking at the joinaliasvars lists, but really this seems like a generic hazard for all expression processing in the planner. Therefore, probably the best answer is to delete the joinaliasvars lists from the parsetree at the end of expression preprocessing, so that there are no reachable expressions that haven't been through preprocessing. The case Andreas found seems to be harmless in non-Assert builds, and so far there are no field reports suggesting that there are user-visible effects in other cases. I considered back-patching this anyway, but it turns out that Andreas' test doesn't fail at all in 9.4-9.6, because in those versions adjust_appendrel_attrs contains code (added in commit 842faa71 and removed again in commit 215b43cd) to process SubLinks rather than complain about them. Barring discovery of another path by which unprocessed joinaliasvars lists can cause trouble, the most prudent compromise seems to be to patch this into v10 but not further. Patch by me, with thanks to Amit Langote for initial investigation and review. Discussion: https://postgr.es/m/87r2tvt9f1.fsf@ansel.ydns.eu
Showing
Please register or sign in to comment