<!-- $PostgreSQL: pgsql/doc/src/sgml/pltcl.sgml,v 2.46 2007/02/21 03:27:31 adunstan Exp $ -->

 <chapter id="pltcl">
  <title>PL/Tcl - Tcl Procedural Language</title>

  <indexterm zone="pltcl">
   <primary>PL/Tcl</primary>
  </indexterm>

  <indexterm zone="pltcl">
   <primary>Tcl</primary>
  </indexterm>

  <para>
   PL/Tcl is a loadable procedural language for the
   <productname>PostgreSQL</productname> database system
   that enables the <ulink url="http://www.tcl.tk/">
   Tcl language</ulink> to be used to write functions and
   trigger procedures.
  </para>

  <!-- **** PL/Tcl overview **** -->

  <sect1 id="pltcl-overview">
   <title>Overview</title>

   <para>
    PL/Tcl offers most of the capabilities a function writer has in
    the C language, with a few restrictions, and with the addition of
    the powerful string processing libraries that are available for
    Tcl.
   </para>
   <para>
    One compelling <emphasis>good</emphasis> restriction is that
    everything is executed from within the safety of the context of a
    Tcl interpreter.  In addition to the limited command set of safe
    Tcl, only a few commands are available to access the database via
    SPI and to raise messages via <function>elog()</>.  PL/Tcl
    provides no way to access internals of the database server or to
    gain OS-level access under the permissions of the
    <productname>PostgreSQL</productname> server process, as a C
    function can do.  Thus, unprivileged database users can be trusted
    to use this language; it does not give them unlimited authority.
   </para>
   <para>
    The other notable implementation restriction is that Tcl functions
    cannot be used to create input/output functions for new data
    types.
   </para>
   <para>
    Sometimes it is desirable to write Tcl functions that are not restricted
    to safe Tcl.  For example, one might want a Tcl function that sends
    email.  To handle these cases, there is a variant of <application>PL/Tcl</> called <literal>PL/TclU</>
    (for untrusted Tcl).  This is the exact same language except that a full
    Tcl interpreter is used.  <emphasis>If <application>PL/TclU</> is used, it must be
    installed as an untrusted procedural language</emphasis> so that only
    database superusers can create functions in it.  The writer of a <application>PL/TclU</>
    function must take care that the function cannot be used to do anything
    unwanted, since it will be able to do anything that could be done by
    a user logged in as the database administrator.
   </para>
   <para>
    The shared object code for the <application>PL/Tcl</> and
    <application>PL/TclU</> call handlers is automatically built and
    installed in the <productname>PostgreSQL</productname> library
    directory if Tcl support is specified in the configuration step of
    the installation procedure.  To install <application>PL/Tcl</>
    and/or <application>PL/TclU</> in a particular database, use the
    <command>createlang</command> program, for example
    <literal>createlang pltcl <replaceable>dbname</></literal> or
    <literal>createlang pltclu <replaceable>dbname</></literal>.
   </para>
  </sect1>

  <!-- **** PL/Tcl description **** -->

   <sect1 id="pltcl-functions">
    <title>PL/Tcl Functions and Arguments</title>

    <para>
     To create a function in the <application>PL/Tcl</> language, use
     the standard <xref linkend="sql-createfunction"
     endterm="sql-createfunction-title"> syntax:

<programlisting>
CREATE FUNCTION <replaceable>funcname</replaceable> (<replaceable>argument-types</replaceable>) RETURNS <replaceable>return-type</replaceable> AS $$
    # PL/Tcl function body
$$ LANGUAGE pltcl;
</programlisting>

     <application>PL/TclU</> is the same, except that the language has to be specified as
     <literal>pltclu</>.
    </para>

    <para>
     The body of the function is simply a piece of Tcl script.
     When the function is called, the argument values are passed as
     variables <literal>$1</literal> ... <literal>$<replaceable>n</replaceable></literal> to the
     Tcl script.  The result is returned
     from the Tcl code in the usual way, with a <literal>return</literal>
     statement.
    </para>

    <para>
     For example, a function
     returning the greater of two integer values could be defined as:

<programlisting>
CREATE FUNCTION tcl_max(integer, integer) RETURNS integer AS $$
    if {$1 &gt; $2} {return $1}
    return $2
$$ LANGUAGE pltcl STRICT;
</programlisting>

     Note the clause <literal>STRICT</>, which saves us from
     having to think about null input values: if a null value is passed, the
     function will not be called at all, but will just return a null
     result automatically.
    </para>

    <para>
     In a nonstrict function,
     if the actual value of an argument is null, the corresponding
     <literal>$<replaceable>n</replaceable></literal> variable will be set to an empty string.
     To detect whether a particular argument is null, use the function
     <literal>argisnull</>.  For example, suppose that we wanted <function>tcl_max</function>
     with one null and one nonnull argument to return the nonnull
     argument, rather than null:

<programlisting>
CREATE FUNCTION tcl_max(integer, integer) RETURNS integer AS $$
    if {[argisnull 1]} {
        if {[argisnull 2]} { return_null }
        return $2
    }
    if {[argisnull 2]} { return $1 }
    if {$1 &gt; $2} {return $1}
    return $2
$$ LANGUAGE pltcl;
</programlisting>
    </para>

    <para>
     As shown above,
     to return a null value from a PL/Tcl function, execute
     <literal>return_null</literal>.  This can be done whether the
     function is strict or not.
    </para>

    <para>
     Composite-type arguments are passed to the function as Tcl
     arrays.  The element names of the array are the attribute names
     of the composite type. If an attribute in the passed row has the
     null value, it will not appear in the array. Here is an example:

<programlisting>
CREATE TABLE employee (
    name text,
    salary integer,
    age integer
);

CREATE FUNCTION overpaid(employee) RETURNS boolean AS $$
    if {200000.0 &lt; $1(salary)} {
        return "t"
    }
    if {$1(age) &lt; 30 && 100000.0 &lt; $1(salary)} {
        return "t"
    }
    return "f"
$$ LANGUAGE pltcl;
</programlisting>
    </para>

    <para>
     There is currently no support for returning a composite-type
     result value, nor for returning sets.
    </para>

    <para>
     <application>PL/Tcl</> does not currently have full support for
     domain types: it treats a domain the same as the underlying scalar
     type.  This means that constraints associated with the domain will
     not be enforced.  This is not an issue for function arguments, but
     it is a hazard if you declare a <application>PL/Tcl</> function
     as returning a domain type.
    </para>

   </sect1>

   <sect1 id="pltcl-data">
    <title>Data Values in PL/Tcl</title>

    <para>
     The argument values supplied to a PL/Tcl function's code are simply
     the input arguments converted to text form (just as if they had been
     displayed by a <command>SELECT</> statement).  Conversely, the
     <literal>return</>
     command will accept any string that is acceptable input format for
     the function's declared return type.  So, within the PL/Tcl function,
     all values are just text strings.
    </para>

   </sect1>

   <sect1 id="pltcl-global">
    <title>Global Data in PL/Tcl</title>

    <indexterm zone="pltcl-global">
     <primary>global data</primary>
     <secondary>in PL/Tcl</secondary>
    </indexterm>

    <para>
     Sometimes it
     is useful to have some global data that is held between two
     calls to a function or is shared between different functions.
     This is easily done since
     all PL/Tcl functions executed in one session share the same
     safe Tcl interpreter.  So, any global Tcl variable is accessible to
     all PL/Tcl function calls and will persist for the duration of the
     SQL session.  (Note that <application>PL/TclU</> functions likewise share
     global data, but they are in a different Tcl interpreter and cannot
     communicate with PL/Tcl functions.)
    </para>
    <para>
     To help protect PL/Tcl functions from unintentionally interfering
     with each other, a global
     array is made available to each function via the <function>upvar</>
     command. The global name of this variable is the function's internal
     name, and the local name is <literal>GD</>.  It is recommended that
     <literal>GD</> be used
     for persistent private data of a function.  Use regular Tcl global
     variables only for values that you specifically intend to be shared among
     multiple functions.
    </para>

    <para>
     An example of using <literal>GD</> appears in the
     <function>spi_execp</function> example below.
    </para>
   </sect1>

   <sect1 id="pltcl-dbaccess">
    <title>Database Access from PL/Tcl</title>

    <para>
     The following commands are available to access the database from
     the body of a PL/Tcl function:

    <variablelist>

     <varlistentry>
      <term><literal><function>spi_exec</function> <optional role="tcl">-count <replaceable>n</replaceable></optional> <optional role="tcl">-array <replaceable>name</replaceable></optional> <replaceable>command</replaceable> <optional role="tcl"><replaceable>loop-body</replaceable></optional></literal></term>
      <listitem>
       <para>
        Executes an SQL command given as a string.  An error in the command
        causes an error to be raised.  Otherwise, the return value of <function>spi_exec</function>
        is the number of rows processed (selected, inserted, updated, or
        deleted) by the command, or zero if the command is a utility
        statement.  In addition, if the command is a <command>SELECT</> statement, the
        values of the selected columns are placed in Tcl variables as
        described below.
       </para>
       <para>
        The optional <literal>-count</> value tells
        <function>spi_exec</function> the maximum number of rows
        to process in the command.  The effect of this is comparable to
        setting up a query as a cursor and then saying <literal>FETCH <replaceable>n</></>.
       </para>
       <para>
        If the command is a <command>SELECT</> statement, the values of the
        result columns are placed into Tcl variables named after the columns.
        If the <literal>-array</> option is given, the column values are
        instead stored into the named associative array, with the
        column names used as array indexes.
       </para>
       <para>
        If the command is a <command>SELECT</> statement and no <replaceable>loop-body</>
        script is given, then only the first row of results are stored into
        Tcl variables; remaining rows, if any, are ignored.  No storing occurs
        if the 
        query returns no rows.  (This case can be detected by checking the
        result of <function>spi_exec</function>.)  For example:
<programlisting>
spi_exec "SELECT count(*) AS cnt FROM pg_proc"
</programlisting>

        will set the Tcl variable <literal>$cnt</> to the number of rows in
        the <structname>pg_proc</> system catalog.
       </para>
       <para>
        If the optional <replaceable>loop-body</> argument is given, it is
        a piece of Tcl script that is executed once for each row in the
        query result.  (<replaceable>loop-body</> is ignored if the given
        command is not a <command>SELECT</>.)  The values of the current row's columns
        are stored into Tcl variables before each iteration.  For example:

<programlisting>
spi_exec -array C "SELECT * FROM pg_class" {
    elog DEBUG "have table $C(relname)"
}
</programlisting>

        will print a log message for every row of <literal>pg_class</>.  This
        feature works similarly to other Tcl looping constructs; in
        particular <literal>continue</> and <literal>break</> work in the
        usual way inside the loop body.
       </para>
       <para>
        If a column of a query result is null, the target
        variable for it is <quote>unset</> rather than being set.
       </para>
      </listitem>
     </varlistentry>

     <varlistentry>
      <term><function>spi_prepare</function> <replaceable>query</replaceable> <replaceable>typelist</replaceable></term>
      <listitem>
       <para>
        Prepares and saves a query plan for later execution.  The
        saved plan will be retained for the life of the current
        session.<indexterm><primary>preparing a query</><secondary>in
        PL/Tcl</></>
       </para>
       <para>
        The query can use parameters, that is, placeholders for
        values to be supplied whenever the plan is actually executed.
        In the query string, refer to parameters
        by the symbols <literal>$1</literal> ... <literal>$<replaceable>n</replaceable></literal>.
        If the query uses parameters, the names of the parameter types
        must be given as a Tcl list.  (Write an empty list for
        <replaceable>typelist</replaceable> if no parameters are used.)
       </para>
       <para>
        The return value from <function>spi_prepare</function> is a query ID
        to be used in subsequent calls to <function>spi_execp</function>. See
        <function>spi_execp</function> for an example.
       </para>
      </listitem>
     </varlistentry>

     <varlistentry>
      <term><literal><function>spi_execp</> <optional role="tcl">-count <replaceable>n</replaceable></optional> <optional role="tcl">-array <replaceable>name</replaceable></optional> <optional role="tcl">-nulls <replaceable>string</replaceable></optional> <replaceable>queryid</replaceable> <optional role="tcl"><replaceable>value-list</replaceable></optional> <optional role="tcl"><replaceable>loop-body</replaceable></optional></literal></term>
      <listitem>
       <para>
        Executes a query previously prepared with <function>spi_prepare</>.
        <replaceable>queryid</replaceable> is the ID returned by
        <function>spi_prepare</>.  If the query references parameters,
        a <replaceable>value-list</replaceable> must be supplied.  This
        is a Tcl list of actual values for the parameters.  The list must be
        the same length as the parameter type list previously given to
        <function>spi_prepare</>.  Omit <replaceable>value-list</replaceable>
        if the query has no parameters.
       </para>
       <para>
        The optional value for <literal>-nulls</> is a string of spaces and
        <literal>'n'</> characters telling <function>spi_execp</function>
        which of the parameters are null values. If given, it must have exactly the
        same length as the <replaceable>value-list</replaceable>.  If it
        is not given, all the parameter values are nonnull.
       </para>
       <para>
        Except for the way in which the query and its parameters are specified,
        <function>spi_execp</> works just like <function>spi_exec</>.
        The <literal>-count</>, <literal>-array</>, and
        <replaceable>loop-body</replaceable> options are the same,
        and so is the result value.
       </para>
       <para>
        Here's an example of a PL/Tcl function using a prepared plan:

<programlisting>
CREATE FUNCTION t1_count(integer, integer) RETURNS integer AS $$
    if {![ info exists GD(plan) ]} {
        # prepare the saved plan on the first call
        set GD(plan) [ spi_prepare \
                "SELECT count(*) AS cnt FROM t1 WHERE num &gt;= \$1 AND num &lt;= \$2" \
                [ list int4 int4 ] ]
    }
    spi_execp -count 1 $GD(plan) [ list $1 $2 ]
    return $cnt
$$ LANGUAGE pltcl;
</programlisting>

        We need backslashes inside the query string given to
        <function>spi_prepare</> to ensure that the
        <literal>$<replaceable>n</replaceable></> markers will be passed
        through to <function>spi_prepare</> as-is, and not replaced by Tcl
        variable substitution.

       </para>
      </listitem>
     </varlistentry>

     <varlistentry>
      <indexterm>
       <primary>spi_lastoid</primary>
      </indexterm>
      <term><function>spi_lastoid</></term>
      <listitem>
       <para>
        Returns the OID of the row inserted by the last
        <function>spi_exec</> or <function>spi_execp</>, if the
        command was a single-row <command>INSERT</> and the modified
        table contained OIDs.  (If not, you get zero.)
       </para>
      </listitem>
     </varlistentry>

     <varlistentry>
      <term><function>quote</> <replaceable>string</replaceable></term>
      <listitem>
       <para>
        Doubles all occurrences of single quote and backslash characters
        in the given string.  This can be used to safely quote strings
        that are to be inserted into SQL commands given
        to <function>spi_exec</function> or
        <function>spi_prepare</function>.
        For example, think about an SQL command string like:

<programlisting>
"SELECT '$val' AS ret"
</programlisting>

        where the Tcl variable <literal>val</> actually contains
        <literal>doesn't</literal>. This would result
        in the final command string:

<programlisting>
SELECT 'doesn't' AS ret
</programlisting>

        which would cause a parse error during
        <function>spi_exec</function> or
        <function>spi_prepare</function>.
        To work properly, the submitted command should contain:

<programlisting>
SELECT 'doesn''t' AS ret
</programlisting>

        which can be formed in PL/Tcl using:

<programlisting>
"SELECT '[ quote $val ]' AS ret"
</programlisting>

        One advantage of <function>spi_execp</function> is that you don't
        have to quote parameter values like this, since the parameters are never
        parsed as part of an SQL command string.
       </para>
      </listitem>
     </varlistentry>

     <varlistentry>
      <indexterm>
       <primary>elog</primary>
       <secondary>in PL/Tcl</secondary>
      </indexterm>
      <term><function>elog</> <replaceable>level</replaceable> <replaceable>msg</replaceable></term>
      <listitem>
       <para>
        Emits a log or error message. Possible levels are
        <literal>DEBUG</>, <literal>LOG</>, <literal>INFO</>,
        <literal>NOTICE</>, <literal>WARNING</>, <literal>ERROR</>, and
        <literal>FATAL</>. <literal>ERROR</>
        raises an error condition; if this is not trapped by the surrounding
        Tcl code, the error propagates out to the calling query, causing
        the current transaction or subtransaction to be aborted.  This
        is effectively the same as the Tcl <literal>error</> command.
        <literal>FATAL</> aborts the transaction and causes the current
        session to shut down.  (There is probably no good reason to use
        this error level in PL/Tcl functions, but it's provided for
        completeness.)  The other levels only generate messages of different
        priority levels.
        Whether messages of a particular priority are reported to the client,
        written to the server log, or both is controlled by the
        <xref linkend="guc-log-min-messages"> and
        <xref linkend="guc-client-min-messages"> configuration
        variables. See <xref linkend="runtime-config"> for more
        information.
       </para>
      </listitem>
     </varlistentry>

    </variablelist>
    </para>

   </sect1>

   <sect1 id="pltcl-trigger">
    <title>Trigger Procedures in PL/Tcl</title>

    <indexterm>
     <primary>trigger</primary>
     <secondary>in PL/Tcl</secondary>
    </indexterm>

    <para>
     Trigger procedures can be written in PL/Tcl.
     <productname>PostgreSQL</productname> requires that a procedure that is to be called
     as a trigger must be declared as a function with no arguments
     and a return type of <literal>trigger</>.
    </para>
    <para>
     The information from the trigger manager is passed to the procedure body
     in the following variables:

     <variablelist>

      <varlistentry>
       <term><varname>$TG_name</varname></term>
       <listitem>
        <para>
         The name of the trigger from the <command>CREATE TRIGGER</command> statement.
        </para>
       </listitem>
      </varlistentry>

      <varlistentry>
       <term><varname>$TG_relid</varname></term>
       <listitem>
        <para>
         The object ID of the table that caused the trigger procedure
         to be invoked.
        </para>
       </listitem>
      </varlistentry>

      <varlistentry>
       <term><varname>$TG_table_name</varname></term>
       <listitem>
        <para>
         The name of the table that caused the trigger procedure
         to be invoked.
        </para>
       </listitem>
      </varlistentry>

      <varlistentry>
       <term><varname>$TG_table_schema</varname></term>
       <listitem>
        <para>
         The schema of the table that caused the trigger procedure
         to be invoked.
        </para>
       </listitem>
      </varlistentry>

      <varlistentry>
       <term><varname>$TG_relatts</varname></term>
       <listitem>
        <para>
         A Tcl list of the table column names, prefixed with an empty list
         element. So looking up a column name in the list with <application>Tcl</>'s
         <function>lsearch</> command returns the element's number starting
         with 1 for the first column, the same way the columns are customarily
         numbered in <productname>PostgreSQL</productname>.  (Empty list
         elements also appear in the positions of columns that have been
         dropped, so that the attribute numbering is correct for columns
         to their right.)
        </para>
       </listitem>
      </varlistentry>

      <varlistentry>
       <term><varname>$TG_when</varname></term>
       <listitem>
        <para>
         The string <literal>BEFORE</> or <literal>AFTER</> depending on the
         type of trigger call.
        </para>
       </listitem>
      </varlistentry>

      <varlistentry>
       <term><varname>$TG_level</varname></term>
       <listitem>
        <para>
         The string <literal>ROW</> or <literal>STATEMENT</> depending on the
         type of trigger call.
        </para>
       </listitem>
      </varlistentry>

      <varlistentry>
       <term><varname>$TG_op</varname></term>
       <listitem>
        <para>
         The string <literal>INSERT</>, <literal>UPDATE</>, or
         <literal>DELETE</> depending on the type of trigger call.
        </para>
       </listitem>
      </varlistentry>

      <varlistentry>
       <term><varname>$NEW</varname></term>
       <listitem>
        <para>
         An associative array containing the values of the new table
         row for <command>INSERT</> or <command>UPDATE</> actions, or
         empty for <command>DELETE</>.  The array is indexed by column
         name.  Columns that are null will not appear in the array.
        </para>
       </listitem>
      </varlistentry>

      <varlistentry>
       <term><varname>$OLD</varname></term>
       <listitem>
        <para>
         An associative array containing the values of the old table
         row for <command>UPDATE</> or <command>DELETE</> actions, or
         empty for <command>INSERT</>.  The array is indexed by column
         name.  Columns that are null will not appear in the array.
        </para>
       </listitem>
      </varlistentry>

      <varlistentry>
       <term><varname>$args</varname></term>
       <listitem>
        <para>
         A Tcl list of the arguments to the procedure as given in the
         <command>CREATE TRIGGER</command> statement. These arguments are also accessible as
         <literal>$1</literal> ... <literal>$<replaceable>n</replaceable></literal> in the procedure body.
        </para>
       </listitem>
      </varlistentry>

     </variablelist>
    </para>

    <para>
     The return value from a trigger procedure can be one of the strings
     <literal>OK</> or <literal>SKIP</>, or a list as returned by the
     <literal>array get</> Tcl command. If the return value is <literal>OK</>,
     the operation (<command>INSERT</>/<command>UPDATE</>/<command>DELETE</>) that fired the trigger will proceed
     normally. <literal>SKIP</> tells the trigger manager to silently suppress
     the operation for this row. If a list is returned, it tells PL/Tcl to
     return a modified row to the trigger manager that will be inserted
     instead of the one given in <varname>$NEW</>.  (This works for <command>INSERT</> and <command>UPDATE</>
     only.) Needless to say that all this is only meaningful when the trigger
     is <literal>BEFORE</> and <command>FOR EACH ROW</>; otherwise the return value is ignored.
    </para>
    <para>
     Here's a little example trigger procedure that forces an integer value
     in a table to keep track of the number of updates that are performed on the
     row. For new rows inserted, the value is initialized to 0 and then
     incremented on every update operation.

<programlisting>
CREATE FUNCTION trigfunc_modcount() RETURNS trigger AS $$
    switch $TG_op {
        INSERT {
            set NEW($1) 0
        }
        UPDATE {
            set NEW($1) $OLD($1)
            incr NEW($1)
        }
        default {
            return OK
        }
    }
    return [array get NEW]
$$ LANGUAGE pltcl;

CREATE TABLE mytab (num integer, description text, modcnt integer);

CREATE TRIGGER trig_mytab_modcount BEFORE INSERT OR UPDATE ON mytab
    FOR EACH ROW EXECUTE PROCEDURE trigfunc_modcount('modcnt');
</programlisting>

     Notice that the trigger procedure itself does not know the column
     name; that's supplied from the trigger arguments.  This lets the
     trigger procedure be reused with different tables.
    </para>
   </sect1>

   <sect1 id="pltcl-unknown">
       <title>Modules and the <function>unknown</> command</title>
       <para>
        PL/Tcl has support for autoloading Tcl code when used.
        It recognizes a special table, <literal>pltcl_modules</>, which
        is presumed to contain modules of Tcl code.  If this table
        exists, the module <literal>unknown</> is fetched from the table
        and loaded into the Tcl interpreter immediately after creating
        the interpreter.
       </para>
       <para>
        While the <literal>unknown</> module could actually contain any
        initialization script you need, it normally defines a Tcl
        <function>unknown</> procedure that is invoked whenever Tcl does
        not recognize an invoked procedure name.  <application>PL/Tcl</>'s standard version
        of this procedure tries to find a module in <literal>pltcl_modules</>
        that will define the required procedure.  If one is found, it is
        loaded into the interpreter, and then execution is allowed to
        proceed with the originally attempted procedure call.  A
        secondary table <literal>pltcl_modfuncs</> provides an index of
        which functions are defined by which modules, so that the lookup
        is reasonably quick.
       </para>
       <para>
        The <productname>PostgreSQL</productname> distribution includes
        support scripts to maintain these tables:
        <command>pltcl_loadmod</>, <command>pltcl_listmod</>,
        <command>pltcl_delmod</>, as well as source for the standard
        <literal>unknown</> module in <filename>share/unknown.pltcl</>.  This module
        must be loaded
        into each database initially to support the autoloading mechanism.
       </para>
       <para>
        The tables <literal>pltcl_modules</> and <literal>pltcl_modfuncs</>
        must be readable by all, but it is wise to make them owned and
        writable only by the database administrator.
       </para>
   </sect1>

   <sect1 id="pltcl-procnames">
    <title>Tcl Procedure Names</title>

    <para>
     In <productname>PostgreSQL</productname>, the same function name can be used for
     different function definitions as long as the number of arguments or their types
     differ. Tcl, however, requires all procedure names to be distinct.
     PL/Tcl deals with this by making the internal Tcl procedure names contain
     the object 
     ID of the function from the system table <structname>pg_proc</> as part of their name. Thus,
     <productname>PostgreSQL</productname> functions with the same name
     and different argument types will be different Tcl procedures, too.  This
     is not normally a concern for a PL/Tcl programmer, but it might be visible
     when debugging.
    </para>

   </sect1>
 </chapter>
